According to Jim (2001)

S2E13 You Gotta Love Somebody (1)

In a special one-hour episode, Cheryl and Jim take on the role of matchmakers for a police officer and his female partner. However, as they attempt to set the stage for romance, they realize their own memories of how they first met differ significantly from the versions shared by Andy and Dana. This discrepancy leads to amusing misunderstandings and highlights the complexities of relationships, as both couples navigate their pasts while trying to bring two others together.